19 Semnături
Petiția este adresată către: Colorado General Assembly
As of time of writing, there is a bill that is under consideration in the Colorado General Assembly called Age Attestation on Computing Devices (SB26-051). It is an age verification bill that requires operating system developers to put age checks in place upon making a new account, in order to put said account into an age bracket that restricts the number of apps they can use based on their age bracket. This could lead to security and privacy issues, as well as directly harming open-source developers. A link to the bill can be found here: https://leg.colorado.gov/bills/SB26-051
motive
Roblox has recently implemented something similar to this proposed bill, and it has issues. A major issue is that it has repeatedly put adults in child age brackets and vice versa, as well as the fact that it is easily bypassed, with one child drawing on their face with a marker and being put in the 21+ age bracket (source 1). The only real way to confirm one's age is through a government-issued ID. However, this imposes privacy and security issues, as demonstrated by a data leak that happened after Discord implemented ID-based age verification in October, where 2 million government IDs were leaked (source 2).
The bill claims that an operating system provider "shall not share an age signal with a third party for a purpose not required by the bill," yet the only thing that happens if they break this rule is that the distributor must pay a fine of up to $2,500 for every minor whose information gets leaked accidentally, and up to $7,500 for every minor whose information gets leaked intentionally. For massive corporations, like Microsoft and Apple, this does virtually nothing, but open-source, nonprofit operating systems, like Linux, will essentially be killed by this bill. Additionally, the bill does not state any form of protection for adults who get their information leaked.
Informații privind petiția
Petiția a fost inițiată:
02.03.2026
Colecția se termină:
03.09.2026
Regiune:
Colorado
categorie:
Protecția consumatorilor
Traduceți această petiție acum
Versiune lingvistică nouăDe ce semnează oamenii
This legislation, especially the intention to construct an age verification API across the internet, lays the groundwork for full Digital ID and identity verification as an upgrade to the pre-existing API that this law puts forth. It boils frogs with sunk cost and begins an iterative process that ends freedom in computing. The best way to stop future encroachment is to stop this initial encroachment.
Also, as a GNU/Linux user, the idea that building an open source operating system myself, without these age verification features, could one day turn into an implication of guilt or a crime in itself. It creates an antitrust crisis where the only "approved" OS is one that has a backing corporation compelled by this law.
You need to get more IT-minded people to weigh in on legislation like this instead of just trying to cram a square peg into a circle hole. This is the beginning of a slippery slope to a rapid loss of personal freedom.
Verifying age at the OS level will not stop bad parenting. There are already ways to set up parental controls on nearly all devices and operating systems and the onus should be on the parents to set those controls up in a way that restricts minors from accessing materials they are not allowed to access. The onus should not be on the developer.
There needs to be major revisions to this. As Linux user & enthusiast, this would only hinder development. Linux powers most of the world's technologies (Android phones, tablets, cars, IoT devices, etc). I'd really encourage to not go down this path because it would limit true free speech in the State of Colorado.
Instrumente pentru distribuirea petiției.
Ai propriul site web, un blog sau un întreg portal web? Devino un susținător și multiplicator pentru această petiție. Avem bannerele, widget-urile și API-ul (interfața) necesare pentru a le integra în site-urile tale. Spre unelte
This is an overreach of the second and fourth amendments